Fatherland is a 1992 alternative history detective novel by english writer and journalist robert harris. Turtledove did have a book wherein germany won wwi. If japan and nazi germany won wwii, can you picture out what america would have looked like. Yes, germany could have won world war i and changed.
Whether victory to you is defined as a crucial military success, or the achievement of your war aims, there is valid points for both sides of the argument. Such writings express ideas of what the world would be like had the axis powers of germany, italy, and japan won world war ii. Germany began construction of bomber bases in iceland, the azores, and the canary islands shirer, 879. The thing that stuck in my mind was that the tone, phrases, attitudes, etc of the book were of the winner writes history slant which would be. The whole book is a psychological horror that takes place in an sanitorium that experiments on people of special interest sexual minorities, mentally ill, etc. The third reich and the united states are locked in a cold war, and harris delights in dropping hints concerning everything that is different as a result of the twist of the historical record. Michael wittmann and the tiger commanders of the leibstandarte 1st edition. Yes, germany could have won world war i and changed history forever yes, this could have happenned. Roosevelts vision that most nearly matched the post 1945 world order that actually materialized. In 1983, it became a highly successful miniseries the winds of war on the abc television network. A plot is thus discovered to eliminate all of those who attended conference to help the improvement of germanys relations with the united states. Dicks brainwarping story is set in a world where the axis powers won world war ii, and america has been divided between japan and nazi germany the brain twisting bit.
What i was looking for is best summarised by lotte eisner in her book on the cinema of fritz lang. What if hitler had made a simple strategy change in 1941. In this massive but thorough meditation, stargardt european historymagdalen coll. In may 1945, as germans regarded the ruins of their devastated country, they faced historys harsh judgment for the brutal and barbaric policies and actions of the third reich. It is twenty years after nazi germanys triumphant victory in world war ii and the.
The story of world war ii seen through the eyes of regular german citizens. What would have happened if germany had won world war i. After all, the booktotvscreen adaptation produced by ridley scott has all the right elements to it its an intelligent show, its lively and fun. The nazis were defeated, and the allies stood victorious. Germanys spring offensive in 1918 broke the frenchbritish line and germany won world war i. Set in a universe in which nazi germany won world war ii, the storys lead. The german war, by nicholas stargardt the new york times. But unsurprisingly, the most chilling vision was hitlers. David cameron visits the graves of first world war soldiers in zonnebeke, belgium. The most popular theme for alternative histories by far is world war ii it would have been possible to populate the entire list with books where the nazis won or the conflicts outcome is drastically different.
Part history, part family saga, i truly enjoyed the winds of war. Alternate history what if germany had won world war i. In many ways, the european theater was a fight over the petroleum adolf hitler needed to fuel the german reich. Harris 1992 novel is among the ultimate alternate world war ii stories. Dick you cant discuss alternate history without bringing up the man in the high castle. So if youre feeling brave, and love good historical fiction, the winds of. With a spitfire in front of buckingham palace and nazi soldiers pointing guns, scenes from a new bbc drama show how london may have looked. Set in 1962 after nazi germany and japan won world war ii in 1948. Various empires and confederations rose and fell throughout german history, often replaced by smaller kingdoms, principalities, and nations that would eventually reunify to form a new version of germany. Set in a universe in which nazi germany won world war ii, the storys lead protagonist is an officer of the kripo, the criminal police, who is investigating the murder of a nazi government official who participated at the wannsee conference. German ww2 luftwaffe book the blonde knight of germany eric hartmann signed. The whole point of germanys warfare was to defeat russia. This semiautobiographical novel of the bosnian war became a bestseller in germany, won the leipzig book fair prize, and has been translated into 31 languages.
The mediterranean strategy for winning world war two chapter one. This book serves to examine just what would have happened if. After winning the war, they continue their plot for war domination, and declare war on japan. Top 10 books about weimar and nazi berlin books the. In 1945 the leader of nazi germany took his own life in an underground bunker surrounded by the smoldering remains of his capital city. Using authoritative sources footnoted the book outlines the war aims of the nazi leadership as if they were realized.
How books became a critical part of the fight to win world war ii. So, was it ever possible for germany to win world war ii. This is perhaps the greatest historical what if of all time. I will not talk about likely, just about possible, and to that the answer is yes. A new history of the second world war in europe 9781442236868. And does anyone know or have a thought about how the world would look in that universe. Written in 1962, its set in a fictional 1962 where nazi germany, fascist italy and imperial japan have won the war and more or less divided the world between themselves see map above. In a way, this is a more interesting hypothesis than the more commonly asked question about what the world would be like if the germans had won world war ii. Uscs had the usgermany winning world war i setting the stage for a nazicsa, but does anyone know of any books where germany wins world war i.
The geopolitical realities germany faces today are similar to the ones it faced during world war ii. Establishment historians characterize national socialist germany as a uniquely barbaric, vile and criminal regime that was totally responsible for starting world war ii and carrying out some of the most heinous war crimes in world history. Not my area of expertise, but john mosiers the myth of the great war. Macleods the summer isles also involves germany winning wwi. The fourth and final part of my world war ii scenario, as i explore what a nazi victory could truly mean in the long term. In september 1944, when adolf hitler first told his. Germany wins world war two alternative history fandom. Bbc drama shows how london might have looked if germany. The best alternative histories in literature on abebooks. For me, the introduction and early chapters of the book did most to help my understanding of the postversailles mentality. New amazon show wonders what life would be like if germany won world war 2. Throughout the book, roberts notes errors that, if avoided, might have helped the germans to win battles and perhaps even the war itself. Basically, in a alternate universe, germany won the battle of britain, stalingrad, kursk and defended successfully at dday. A new military history of world war i made sense to me though consider that i could be biased because his conclusions are rather complimentary to ame.
The father takes down a globe and runs his hand across. Explosive book reveals former presidents praise for the nazis as he travelled through germany before second world war. The nation of germany has a long history of unity and separation. Numerous examples exist in several languages worldwide. In this timeline, aids has posed a greater threat to the point. Several historians have noted that both world wars should really be considered a single conflict with a long armistice in the middle. Elizabeth i was murdered and the catholics are in charge this book is set in a feudal dorset in 1968. North africa february 1941 erwin rommel stepped out of the junkers aircraft and squinted in the blinding tunisian sun. It is an unsanitised, closely analysed, account of germany at war. Such writings express ideas of what the world would be like had the axis powers of germany, italy and japan won world war ii. Germanys war documents that the allied leaders of the soviet union, great britain and the united states were primarily responsible for starting and prolonging world war iicosting million of lives. With the collapse of the soviet union, america stood alone. Map by morgan hauser via wikimedia what if hitler and the nazis had won world war ii. I seem to remember somebody mentioning a what if fiction book that looked back at wwii after the fact, written as if germany had won wwii.
This can be the breeding ground for the battles of the ho229, kitsuka, j7w, r2y etc. The book was recently adapted into a critically acclaimed television series by. Despite the fact that i now have an aching wrist from holding this monster for three days, im already 300 pages into the next book, war and remembrance. What if germany had given erwin rommel the resources that great britain had deployed in the middle east.
He is a principal antagonist of the book who is personally responsible for the assassinations of the wannsee officials. If they win a short war in 1914, with the schlieffen plan the plan to quickly defeat the french first to avoid fighting on two fronts working, its different than if they win a negotiated victory after a long, hard fight at the end of 1916 or early in 1917, which is the other possibility. World war ii set humanity on a path to our modern world. Getting britain out of the war, as early as possible, would have been a major success. Germanys war by john wear refutes this characterization of germany, bringing history into accord with the facts. The thing that stuck in my mind was that the tone, phrases, attitudes, etc of the book were of the winner writes history slant which would be so odd to us today. The nazis made several strategic mistakes that contributed to. A hypothetical axis victory in world war ii has become a common concept of alternative history and counterfactual history. Hypothetical axis victory in world war ii wikipedia. Dick is one of the first alternate history novels to look at an axis victory in world war two. Sasa stanisic wins 2019 german book prize publishing. Far from being the conqueror of europe, adolf hitler saved it from stalin. How germany could have won ww ii using a mediterranean strategy.
Brendan gallagher has dedicated much of his life to the study and practice of war. Published in 1971, it was followed up seven years later by war and remembrance. Germany s war documents that the allied leaders of the soviet union, great britain and the united states were primarily responsible for starting and prolonging world war iicosting million of lives. Below are three maps, from three different books, representing three fictional scenarios where germany does win the war. And no one would deny that postworld war ii germany has become a beacon of liberal democratic principles and a.
21 952 551 286 327 1038 1407 1430 5 341 514 515 373 1280 1230 738 1503 1048 1244 98 1280 8 1319 714 705 1062 181 1001